Carl Deal was thrilled to think his documentary on the role of corporate bigwigs in Wisconsin’s crackdown on public employee unions would air on public television.
“It was a really appropriate venue for how the money of a few can drown out the voices of the many,” says Deal, co-director of “Citizen Koch,” a film that critically examines the profusion of corporate cash in the political process, with an accompanying website that encourages an activist response.
But a funny thing happened on the way to the forum that public television provides. The Independent Television Service (ITVS), the arm of PBS that funds documentaries, withdrew its initial support.
That’s unleashed a whirlwind of controversy, including a recent article in The New Yorker and a skewering by the nation’s jester-in-chief, Stephen Colbert.
ITVS allegedly dropped “Citizen Koch” to avoid further aggravating billionaire industrialist David Koch, a major backer of both conservative causes and public TV. David and brother Charles Koch founded the advocacy group Americans for Prosperity, which along with the Kochs’ company is a major backer of Wisconsin Gov. Scott Walker.
David Koch has also given $23 million over the years to public television, The New Yorker reported. He served on the board of New York’s public television affiliate, WNET, to which he was planning to make, a source told the magazine, “a seven-figure donation — maybe more.”
Deal says ITVS reacted enthusiastically to a rough cut of the film, offering up to $215,000 in funding, a substantial share of its cost. But things went south after PBS last November aired another documentary, “Park Avenue,” that cast David Koch in an unflattering light. Koch ultimately quit the WNET board and spiked his planned donation, The New Yorker reported.
WNET president Neal Shapiro contacted ITVS to voice his concerns, at one point threatening to stop airing its films, which The New Yorker called “a potentially mortal blow to ITVS” because New York is its largest market. Deal and co-director Tia Lessin say ITVS officials pressured them to drop “Koch” from their film’s title and de-emphasize the brothers’ role.
In April, ITVS told the filmmakers it was no longer backing the project. Deal calls it a lesson on “the influence that private donors can have on public television.” Lessin notes that the chairman of the ITVS board is Garry Denny, director of programming for Wisconsin Public Television.
“I think the folks in Wisconsin should call him into account,” Lessin said.
Denny deferred comment to spokespeople at ITVS and Wisconsin Public Television.
ITVS spokeswoman Amna Mirza says the board played no role in the decision to end negotiations over “Citizen Koch,” but has been kept closely informed on the fallout. Amplifying on a statement from her group, she asserts that the filmmakers made “a major shift in editorial direction” from their original concept.
Deal and Lessin insist the final film is “identical in premise and execution to the written and video proposals that ITVS green-lit” last year.
Michael Harryman, spokesman for Wisconsin Public Television, says it would consider airing “Citizen Koch,” which he agrees would have audience interest because it deals with Wisconsin characters and events. (It played to packed houses at the Wisconsin Film Festival in April.)
“We’ve never shied away from showing anything controversial, unless we pick up on a strong sense of bias or editorialization,” Harryman says. “If they send us the film, we’ll look at it.”
Deal says the filmmakers, who’ve issued a statement on the controversy, are exploring other options for national release.
According to Harryman, state lawmakers who control about a third of WPT’s $12 million annual budget and major donors have not tried to dictate content. But ordinary viewers do sometimes vow to stop donating over something that airs.
“While we welcome feedback, we can’t allow it to dictate our programming choices,” Harryman says. “We’re stewards of the public airwaves.”
It’s an awesome responsibility that no one should take lightly.
Sure would be nice if public tv made some documentaries on some of those liberal fat cats.
The fearful retreat of the inappropriately named Independent Television Service just reinforces the central message of the film “Citizen Koch.”
The ITVS is obviously NOT independent and is doing a DISservice to the public by cheating us all of free and easy viewing of this vitally important film on our home TVs.
It’s appalling that Republican extremists have slashed Public TV’s budgets to the point that just one private Republican donor can now dictate what we’re allowed to see on OUR public television channel.
In response to Jan’s comment: If you think a worthwhile and factual documentary can be made about “liberal fat cats,” you’re perfectly free to go and make it. Public TV didn’t make or pay for the “Citizen Koch” documentary that we’re discussing here. It was made by independent individuals with their own time and money, and the facts and events included in the film are well-documented and verifiable. If you produce a film of equal quality, urgency and relevance from another viewpoint, I believe you should have an equal right to air it on Public TV.
I don’t think it’s surprising that someone (e.g. Koch) who believes that he will be vilified in a documentary might choose not to provide funds or publicity to the makers of the documentary. I know as someone of modest income, I would not support a store that treats me poorly. The station should be free to show the film and Koch should be free to support whatever films/projects he wishes.
Also, nothing is stopping the filmmakers from putting the entire documentary on YouTube where everyone could watch it anywhere and anytime.